It was about a year and a half ago that I wrote a post about how studies over the past several years are showing that foods using artificial sweeteners, like diet sodas, may not be so good if you are trying to get fit and lose weight. It seems that the exact details are still being ironed out, but several theories continue to emerge.
As I’ve discussed previously, even though artificial sweeteners have no calories research has shown they can cause you to gain weight. It seems that science has found that the brain makes an association between taste and the caloric content of food and drink. When you taste it, the brain triggers mechanisms in the body that prepare for the calories to burn. When those calories don’t arrive, the body triggers cravings in order to get the calories it was expecting. And, think about when you have cravings. Do you eat a sensible amount? I didn’t think so.Now, if you are in seriously working out with a fitness routine with the goal to lose weight, gain muscle, get ripped, or all of the above, you need to maximize the nutritional value of everything you eat. This means limiting cravings is imperative.
Foods with little or no nutritional value, so called “empty calories”, can sabotage you. While there are little to no calories, it seems that the body doesn’t quite metabolize the ingredients right:
Fructose, a primary ingredient in many sodas, cannot be broken down into useful energy. For this reason it is stored directly as fat.
Studies have also shown there may be a link between artificial sweeteners and the amount of energy used by the body:
In a study designed to measure energy expenditure, the saccharin-conditioned rats had slightly lower energy expenditures after eating a high-calorie meal containing sugar.
Does this mean you should cut soda out of your diet completely? That’s up to you, and depending on your fitness goals, it just may be necessary. For me doing P90X, I try to severely limit my intake of soda. I try to drink mostly water, but every now and then I do want something to drink with taste so I’ll have a glass, but that’s about it. And by every now and then, I mean once a week, if that. Based on what I’ve what discussed with friends and read, I don’t drink soda regularly and it’s something I suggest to others.
When looking into the nutritional value of food and drink, don’t just look at the calories, carbs, fat, and protein. Look at the other ingredients as well. Look at what kinds of artificial sweeteners are used. The balance between the quantity and quality of foods is key, and it appears from recent research that artificial sweeteners can throw off that balance. Sodas are ok occasionally and in moderation, but I don’t think it would be a good idea to down a can after your workout.
